Simplifying PostgreSQL Restarts: How to Choose the Right Mode for Your Needs

Three Restart Modes in PostgreSQL

1. smart mode (-m smart) - Gentle & Safe

Waits patiently for all clients to disconnect on their own
Completes all transactions normally before shutting down
No data loss - everything commits properly
Best for production during active hours
Slowest method but most graceful

2. fast mode (-m fast) - Quick & Controlled

Rolls back active transactions immediately
Disconnects all clients abruptly but safely
Restarts quickly without waiting
No data corruption - maintains database integrity
Perfect for maintenance windows
Medium risk - some transactions get aborted

3. immediate mode (-m immediate) - Emergency Only

Forceful shutdown like a crash
No waiting - kills everything immediately
May require recovery on next startup
Risk of temporary inconsistencies
Only for emergencies when nothing else works
PostgreSQL will automatically recover using WAL logs

💡 Key Points to Remember:

All three modes are safe for the database itself
Data integrity is maintained through WAL (Write-Ahead Logging)
Choose based on your situation: gentle vs fast vs emergency
Fast mode is completely normal for planned maintenance
Always warn users before using fast or immediate modes

🚀 When to Use Each:

Use smart mode when:
Database is in production use
You can afford to wait
No transactions should be interrupted

Use fast mode when:
You need to restart quickly
During maintenance windows
Some transaction rollback is acceptable

Use immediate mode when:
Database is unresponsive
Emergency situations only
You have no other choice

All modes will bring your database back safely - they just differ in how gently they treat connected clients and active transactions!